Directory Image
This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By using our website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

Why perform PCB thermal simulations

Author: Roy Green
by Roy Green
Posted: Nov 24, 2019

As all electronics engineers and PCB designers should know, electronics components generate heat during their operation and many (particularly processors and high power LED’s) are liable to overheat and malfunction if they are not adequately cooled. By far the most common solution for electronics cooling is the use of an air cooled heat sink, coupled with a DC cooling fan. How do we know which size and geometry of heat sink to use or what air velocity is required to achieve adequate cooling? We could perform some calculations with pen and paper, however if we want our results to be accurate, the solution is to perform a computational thermal simulation to accurately calculate component temperature. The main advantages of performing the computational thermal simulations include:

1. It Enables performance to be assessed prior to enclosure fabrication

By running computational thermal simulations during the design stage, engineers can collect data to guide them in making important design decisions that will impact the ability of the electronics to remain cool. The thermal simulations will ultimately improve the design outcome for the product which will also help you to avoid needlessly going through several design and fabrication iterations to achieve the desired electronics cooling. The additional design iterations not only result in time delays, they also cost a lot of money. As a result, companies who attempt to save time and money by forgoing simulations will often find themselves paying significantly more in the long run.

2. To collect more test data, lots and lots more!

Owing to computer simulations being faster to perform (than fabricating and testing a prototype), they allow us to test a much larger set of operating conditions, thereby giving us an increased understanding about how the product or process operates and what the relationships between different parameters are. Whereas performing an experiment to collect several dozen data points might take a day, a simulation can collect thousands or millions of datapoints in the same time. This is something that is simply not possible by any other means.

3. We can acquire data that cannot be acquired experimentally

The thermal simulations will provide us with data, including the component temperature and the surrounding air velocity, at all points within the 3 dimensional space. This is something that would be very difficult to achieve experimentally and is probably also a lot more expensive. Furthermore, experiments cannot rival simulations in terms of the sheer quantity of data that can be collected. It is therefore significantly easier to see patterns and trends in the data through simulations than through experimental results.

4. They are more accurate than ’pen and paper’ calculations

Although pen and paper calculations of heat loss will often provide us with satisfactory results when used in simple cases such as that of natural convection heat transfer from a flat plate, they are not well suited for solving more complicated scenarios such as those involving complex geometries and forced air flows. Simulations are far more adept at modelling these kinds of scenarios and so they allow us to be more confident with our results.

About the Author

Flowtek designs product enclosures for electrical, electronic and optical products (among others). Our services include mechanical design, thermal and structural analysis, prototype manufacturing and thermal testing of prototypes.

Rate this Article
Leave a Comment
Author Thumbnail
I Agree:
Comment 
Pictures
Author: Roy Green

Roy Green

Member since: Nov 21, 2019
Published articles: 1

Related Articles