Not All Firings Are Legal — But How Do You Know If Yours Was?

Losing your job is never easy. Whether it came out of the blue or followed months of workplace tension, being fired can feel deeply personal — and often leaves people wondering if what happened was even legal. Employers are allowed to terminate employment, yes, but only under certain conditions. And the line between a lawful dismissal and an unfair one is thinner than many realise.

If your termination felt unjustified, retaliatory, or discriminatory, it's worth examining more closely. Speaking with an unfair dismissal lawyer early on can help clarify whether what happened falls within legal bounds — or crosses the line into wrongful conduct. But even before you seek professional advice, there are red flags and patterns you can watch for.

Let’s break it down.

Was There a Valid Reason for the Termination?

In many cases, an employer must have a legitimate, documented reason to fire someone. This includes poor performance, serious misconduct, or a genuine redundancy. But even then, the process must follow clear procedures.

Ask yourself:

• Were you given warnings or opportunities to improve?
• Did your employer follow company disciplinary policies?
• Was there an investigation or fair hearing before you were let go?

If the answer to these is no, you may have grounds to question the legality of the dismissal.

Process Matters: Was the Firing Carried Out Fairly?

Even when a reason exists, the law requires that dismissals are procedurally fair. That means your employer must give you a chance to respond, be clear about expectations, and document all steps along the way. Being abruptly fired without explanation or without the opportunity to discuss allegations is not just unprofessional — it can be unlawful.

You might also ask:

• Did I receive any official communication about the termination?
• Was I allowed to bring a support person to any disciplinary meetings?
• Was I given a fair timeline or notice period?

Skipping these steps can make an otherwise valid dismissal unfair.

Was There Discrimination, Retaliation, or Harassment?

This is where things become more serious. If your firing followed complaints you made about workplace bullying, safety concerns, or discrimination, it might not be a coincidence. The law protects employees from retaliation, especially when they've exercised their legal rights.

Warning signs include:

• Being dismissed shortly after raising a complaint
• Having your hours cut or role changed without explanation
• Receiving poor reviews after previously being praised

These can point to deeper issues that go beyond performance.

Redundancy Isn't a Blank Cheque

Sometimes employers label a firing as "redundancy" to avoid scrutiny. But redundancy has a very specific meaning under employment law. The role itself must no longer be needed — not just that your employer wants to replace you with someone cheaper or more compliant.

If your position still exists, or someone else is hired to do the same job, it likely isn’t a genuine redundancy. That could make the dismissal challengeable.

You Don’t Have to Be Silent

Many people stay quiet because they feel powerless, embarrassed, or afraid of being seen as "difficult." But if you believe something is off, it’s better to ask questions early. You have rights, and enforcing them doesn’t mean you’re being dramatic — it means you’re protecting yourself.

Here are some ways to take control:

• Request your termination details in writing
• Keep records of emails, meetings, and any performance reviews
• Seek support from a union, industry body, or workplace ombudsman

Most importantly, don’t rely on workplace gossip or assumptions. Get informed by people who understand the law.

When to Seek Legal Advice

Not every dismissal is unlawful, but many aren’t as clean-cut as they appear. If you're unsure, a short consultation with an employment expert can be invaluable. They’ll help you assess whether it’s worth pursuing a case, what evidence is needed, and what your options are moving forward — including compensation or reinstatement.

Some situations that definitely warrant professional advice:

• You weren’t given notice or severance
• You were fired after returning from maternity leave or while on sick leave
• You were told to resign or face termination
• You were dismissed during a probation period without a clear reason

Remember: time limits for lodging unfair dismissal claims are short. Don’t wait too long to act.

Your Next Step Doesn’t Have to Be a Lawsuit

Legal action is just one path. Sometimes, a calm but firm letter, a mediated conversation, or formal complaint to a regulator can lead to a fair outcome. Many disputes are resolved privately and without courtroom drama.

Your goal isn't to "get revenge" — it’s to ensure your rights were respected and to prevent the same thing from happening to someone else.

Moving Forward with Confidence

Being fired can shake your confidence, even if you know it wasn’t your fault. But understanding your rights and options puts the power back in your hands. Whether you challenge the dismissal or use the moment to pivot in your career, the key is not to let fear or shame keep you stuck.

You deserved clarity, respect, and fairness — and if you didn’t get that, you’re within your rights to question it. Get informed, stay calm, and know that not all firings are final chapters. Sometimes, they’re just the start of something better.

I'm a professional writer and author of many sites. I want to explore the world through my writing.